×

Please choose your language

لطفا زبان خود را مشخص کنید

×
We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Ok, thanks Learn more
پرينت خبر

Gegli news - Warship leak 'embarrassing' but worse things have happened at sea - 12/20/2017 9:12:27 AM 9:12:27 AM 

A leak of 200 litres an hour on a ship this size will simply create a big puddle, says Sky defence correspondent Alistair Bunkall.

 It makes for a good headline but the reality is the leak onboard HMS Queen Elizabeth is nothing to worry about.

Leaks on ships occur from time to time. One former sailor I spoke to says it happened "on multiple occasions on different ships throughout my career".

HMS Queen Elizabeth is currently undergoing sea trials - the very purpose of this programme is to find and fix faults.

In this case the leak is from a faulty seal around the prop shaft, a bit like a faulty washer. Divers need to go down, find it and replace the seal.

She is in Portsmouth - her home port - and she will be repaired there.

The Queen at the ceremony for HMS Queen Elizabeth
Image:The Queen attended the ceremony for HMS Queen Elizabeth

A leak of 200 litres an hour, on a ship this size, will create a big puddle. If it was bigger, she would have to go into dry docks for repair - that would be more serious because there isn't a facility near Portsmouth and it would almost certainly have an impact on her trials.

The Navy knew about the leak when the Queen was on board last week for the Commissioning ceremony.

This does make it a little embarrassing because of all the fanfare that went into that day, but when asked why they didn't come clean and reveal the leak then, the answer was: "Because it's just routine stuff - honestly, we don't give these things a second thought.

It is worth noting that if the leak was genuinely significant then the Navy might have decided not to accept her into service until it was sorted.

It is also good to include some historical comparisons - the Astute submarine programme also had a leak issue, but far more serious.

One of the nuclear-powered hunter killer submarines had to perform an emergency surface when water started coming in. That wasn't good.

Dozens of spectators lined Portsmouth Harbour to witness HMS Queen Elizabeth's arrival
Image:Spectators lined Portsmouth Harbour to witness the carrier's arrival in the summer

Only today, the MOD has been roundly criticised for another big equipment programme, the F35.

The defence select committee has said it is "unacceptable" that the military cannot say how much a single jet will cost and have warned that the aircraft carrier will need much stronger bandwidth than it currently has, if it is to perform properly.


What do you think about this news?

Tell everyone your opinion on this news

To leave your opinion click the link below to login to Gegli

Login